Monday, December 5, 2011

Puppet Making Journal


Since I had missed the previous session where my classmates began their puppet making/paper mache experience, I just had to jump right into it. At first, it was a little intimidating because it seemed as though everyone knew what they were doing, and I saw a variety of different styles and creative choices. Luckily I was able to join a group that had already been established and Ms. Gwathmey provided a book and some helpful instruction about making a hand puppet.

I noticed that there were many different art techniques that went into the puppet making. There was a design component, paper mache, sewing, and painting. The paper mache and design were relatively easy for me to pick up, but the sewing was a little more difficult. I come from a family of talented seamstresses. My great grandfather was a successful tailor. He taught my grandmother how to sew, my father is an excellent surgeon, and my older sister also picked up on the skill. When we were little, and used to play with dolls, I would come up with extensive imaginary games, while my sister would sew them detailed ensembles. A few people over the years attempted to teach me how to sew, but I never really picked up the skill. Looking back now, I think I was jealous and intimidated by the advanced abilities of my family members and I let that inhibit me from learning the skill they excelled in because I feared that I wouldn’t be as good at it.

One of my group members was very encouraging and walked me through some of the sewing questions I had. In a classroom, students will have various skills and be naturally talented in certain capacities while they may struggle in others. As teachers, we won’t necessarily be able to know all of the stories as to why they excel or struggle, but it’s our role to be aware and allow them to shine and encourage them when necessary.

My Paper Mache Puppet

11.17.11 Paper Mache!

I was absent for the initial explanation of paper mache, but was able to pick up on making a puppet the follow class.

Response to Environment Study Slide Show

In every class, other then art, apparently I have a problem with designing age appropriate and well spaced out curriculum. I recently designed a science themed trip to the metropolitan museum of art for what I thought would be appropriate for first graders. The questions and activities were all beyond the capacity of a typical six year old. After being told that, I reviewed my paper and realized that even though the trip, activities, and exploratory questions were well thought out, it wasn’t developmentally appropriate. I could still take the six graders to the same exhibit in the museum, I would just have to frame the activities differently and ask more general questions that they can understand.

I told this story because if reminds me of the slide show Ms. Gwathmey showed us about different levels of students studying their environment using the arts. Bank Street does a really excellent job of allowing children to ‘do’ and learn about the world around them. The pictures in the slide show showed various studies of the environment from the age of 4-10. Each age group was studying their environment at a level they could understand. The 4/5 year olds went to Central Park and recreated a map of the park; the 5/6 created their own bakery; 7/8 built a model of the Hudson River and learned its history; the 8/9 studied New Amsterdam and participated in art projects and crafts that would have been done at that time; 9/10 studied the continent of Africa and again, participated in art projects and crafts that would have been done in the places they studied. With each additional age, the children were able to explore an environment in a slightly more abstract way. This kind of thinking is only possible once the concrete ways of thinking have been exercised.

Analysis of Children's Paintings





Nancy Smith: Experience & Art

  1. Pre-representation Stage

a. Motions and the marks they make (In this stage, children age 1.5-3 are focused on ‘motoric and kinesthetic sensations’ (page 6), painting with repetitive and jerky movements.

Description and Analysis: This child used blue and gray paint. There are two blue circles, one larger than the other, that are connected by one of the circle motions made in the larger circle. To the right of the larger circle there is an oval-like gray shape that has short horizontal and diagonal lines coming out of it. Over the three shapes, there are multiple blue and gray slightly faded sweeping lines. The painting is mostly in the center of the paper.

I put this painting in this first stage because of the circular motions and reflex-like nature of the sweeping brush strokes. There is not much variation in color; the child only used blue and gray. It appeared as though they were experimenting in different ways of using the paintbrush; up and down, round and round, zigzag. “Three year olds repeat the same kind of lines and shapes on top of each other, creating inadvertent order.” (Page 13)

Possible motivation: Explore what your brush can do. What kinds of shapes, lines, and dots can you make?

Comment to painter: “I see you chose to paint with blue and gray. There are lines on your paper that go up and down and side-to-side.”

b. Finding out about lines, shapes, and colors (In this stage, children age 3-5, have a greater understanding of graphic concepts. Their hand-eye coordination is more advanced, as is their understanding of lines, shapes, and colors. Their actions become slightly more direct.)

Description and Analysis: This child used red, blue, black, and orange paint. There is a thick, orange horizontal base shape that resembles a rectangle. On top of the orange base, there is a blob-like shape that is mostly red, with some mixing of black and a little blue. A few thin orange lines stick out of the right side of the entire shape as well as one floating above it.

I put this painting in the second sub-category of the first stage because the painter used “irregular and rambling shapes and also squares or rectangles.” (Page 24) They began mixing some colors on the paper, creating new colors, but still keeping some of the colors separate.

Possible motivation: What happens when you mix colors on your paper?

Comment to painter: “I see you mixed red, black, and orange on your paper. The mixing of the colors made a darker color, especially when you mixed black with red.

c. Design (In this stage, children age 4-6, use a more complex combination of lines, shapes, and colors. The arrangements of these various components really begin to stand out.)

Description and Analysis: This child used pink, purple, green, blue, and red circles. The same colored lines connect them. On top of the web-like design, there are multi colored, almost rainbow colored dots that go two parallel horizontal lines and trail off into one vertical line. On the bottom right corner, there is a yellow oval.

I put this painting in the third sub-category of the first page because the “the results of this concentration and deliberation are revealed in the careful order of their designs.” (Page 33) The child made the “configuration fit together as a whole on the paper.” (Page 32) The circles being connected with lines appeared to be such a deliberate design choice on the part of the painter. I additionally found the complex mixing of colors in the small dots quite pertinent to this stage of development.

Possible Motivation: What is a design? Think about the different components that can go into a design and use some of them today. Feel free to mix colors, as you like.

Comment to painter: “I see many circles on your page of different colors. You connected them with lines using the same colors. I see that you mixed some of those colors into the dots that line the top and side of your page.”

  1. Simple Images (In this stage, children age 5-7, are able to use logical thought and have more organized minds. They tend to paint in general categories initially and then later add sub-categories such as gender. Indicators are additionally added to scenes that determine if they are depicting an indoor or outdoor scene.)

Description and Analysis: This child painted a blue sky, a yellow sun, yellow grass, and a brown and black leopard. The grass is made up of tall, parallel, vertical, yellow lines. The sky is made up of blue zig zaggy lines. The head is a square; the ears are small circles, the body, legs and tail and rectangles. The black spots are pretty evenly spaced throughout the animal.

I put this painting in the simple images category because the painter painted the “the essential parts of an object, relating them to the basic graphic elements they have learned (circle, rectangle, line, and dot) and assembling whole symbols…” (Page 59)

Possible motivation: What is your favorite animal?

Comment to painter: “I see you drew an animal with spots. It has a long tail. The sun is in the center of your painting. It’s very big and yellow.

  1. Richer Symbols: Friends, Workers, City Streets (In this stage, children 7-9, have a larger range of interests and know about more things and places. They are hungry for knowledge and do not necessarily paint in perspective.)

Description and Analysis: This child painted a red dragon with orange fire coming out of its mouth. It is standing in front of a gray/blue/green castle with a small red flag on the top on it. They obviously mixed their own colors, creating an olive/yellow green, a pinkinsh red, and the previously mentioned gray/blue/green.

I put this painting in the Richer Symbols category because the painting is not in perspective. “In the representation of space children are still indifferent to the convention of perspective; nevertheless they design the whole paper as a unit of space.” (Page 77)All of the choices made in this painting appear to be deliberate and that the artist was clear about the object, in this case a dragon in front of a castle, they chose to paint.

Possible motivation: Paint animals with tails.

Comment to painter: “I see you mixed some of your own colors in this painting. What colors did you use to make the light green color? You used a lot of detail in the dragon, with the black lines on the wings, the horns, the fire, the blue eyes, and the arms and legs.

  1. Metaphors and Styles: The Den of a Wolf, A Cat on a Cushion (In this stage, children age 9-11, begin to use metaphors in order to depict emotions or concepts. They show interest in specific styles of painting, shadowing, cartoons, and have a heightened awareness of perspective.)

Description and Analysis: This child painted a scene with two artists: a painter and a dancer. There is a sky-line with a vibrant choice of firey colors. The painter is in the front center o the pager and had facial attributes that depict contentment or happiness. The dancer is in the left side of the page and is in a familiar dance pose.

I put this painting in the Metaphors and Styles category because the painter clearly depicted emotion in the artist they painted. There is clearly a heightened sense of perspective that can be seen with the size of the easel in relation to the painter, as well as the smaller size of the dance that appear as though they are supposed to be more in the background. The fiery use of colors in the sky is vibrant and gives off a warm and inspiring feel.

Possible motivation: What is your favorite hobby?

Comment to painter: There is a lot of detail in your piece. The designs in the sweater, the paint colors on the easel, the highlights in the painter’s hair, and the vibrant colors of the sky.

  1. Luna’s Painting Exploration

Description: Luna, age 3, used orange, black, red, green, purple, white, and yellow in this painting. The colors remained relatively separate. She painted the colors in thick horizontals lines on top of each other. The orange line surrounds the entire pile of lines. On the left bottom corner, she made orange dots that are slightly overlapping.

I put this painting in the second sub-category of the first stage of learning the elements because she used a vaiety of colors and similar shaped lines. “Often they try to keep the colors separate,” (Page 24) which she chose to do.

Motivation: I presented Luna with a new set of paints. Instead of giving her an idea of what to paint, I demonstrated a process of painting with different colors. First I dipped the paint into a specific color, painted with it, put the brush in water, dabbed it with a wet paper towel, and then chose a new color with the clean brush.

Response to Rika Burnham's If You Don't Stop, You Don't See Anything

The more I read about it and experience it, the more I realize that art is a very difficult subject to teach. There is so much judgment about what is good art, what is bad art, what is significant about a particular piece, which the most important artist are and why. The language used in art can be very “mysterious” to those who aren’t around it all the time, which unfortunately, is a growing number of people as art programs are quickly being taken out of schools and curriculum.

This growing lack of knowledge, ignorance if you may, like all ignorance, can create fear within people, as well as their own judgments. SO when a student is presented with a reference to a specific art time period or noted style of painting, and they have no previous context in which they could have learned this, it’s expected that their reaction might not always be excitement. They may become embarrassed by their lack of knowledge; or they may tune out whatever is being said to them because they don’t understand it.

A teacher should never assume that everyone has the same common knowledge about a subject. I remember, when I was younger, I switched from private school to public in middle school. There were some subjects that were taught differently in my previous school system and a few topics that I hadn’t learned. I remember very clearly asking in math class once what a certain idea meant and my teacher snapped back at me saying, ‘you should know that.” Regardless of the fact that the specific idea should have been ‘common knowledge’ for me by this stage in my development, I didn’t know it. Furthermore, as a teacher, one should not make a student feel bad about not knowing something they may not have taught them. Teachers need to be patient and aware that students internalize different topics at different speeds. Sometimes it’s okay to go back, take it slow, and re-teach something, or even listen to you students and learn from them. This idea relates to art as well. As expressed by Rika Burnham when referencing a museum trip with her students,

“It was time for me to stop lecturing and begin listening, not only to what the students had o say about art, but what they had to say about the experience of art.”

The doing and observing of art can be such a uniquely different experience for every person. So putting a lot of per-conceived ideas onto young minds as to what it ‘should’ be can be stifling and not inspirational. The history and previous analysis of art has it’s place but so does allowing fresh eyes to make new observations. “The greatest gift we can give our students in the museum is the acceptance of their responses”. As teachers we must let them find joy in ‘looking and thinking”.

Field Trip to the Metropolitan Muesum of Art


I missed the initial museum trip experience due to illness and had the opportunity to make up the trip. I brought my three-year-old daughter Luna with me, which made the experience very interesting, getting to see her perspective on the art we were observing. We focused on only one section of African masks.

I found it very interesting when Ms. Gwathmey said that on trips, it’s a. and M focus completely on one. This is a very opposing idea to how school trips I went on to the Metropolitan Museum of Art went as a child. They were sensory overloads, missions for too much information. I feel that this slow pace and sole focus could make for a significantly richer trip.

When looking at the masks we noted the varying shapes, colors, positions, and tried to visualize how they were actually worn. My daughter pointed these details out quite clearly, and once most of the class left, she positioned herself like two of the masks. One was upside down and the other was a squatting monkey.

We were asked to draw at least one of the masks. I did a very simple sketch of one of them and took a picture of all of them as well. I drew a flat version of a 3-dimensional mask and wondered, while drawing, if the inability to draw 3-dimentionally would bother children of a certain age. Probably the younger children wouldn’t notice as much, but I would imagine the older ones wanting to do a more accurate representation. Luna had no interest in drawing the masks; she drew a ‘volcano house’ instead.

Once the trip was over, I let Luna lead me around where she wanted to go. She was fascinated with many of the European sculptures of people. She commented on their color and the moods they appeared to be in. “He looks sad, where is his mommy? This one fell down…that one is broken.” Going through a few exhibits and seeing her very concrete perspective was fascinating.